How do you know when it’s time to rebrand?
Rebrands are often dismissed as expensive vanity projects, cosmetic logo swaps, or something you do when growth slows and you don’t know what else to fix.
Related Article Block Placeholder
Article ID: 328829
After 15 years of creating and recreating brands, I’ve seen it all. The CMO who comes in and wants to leave their mark. The founder who should have rebranded but was too emotionally attached to what they had created, despite what the data showed us. The rebrand that could have been great, but was watered down.
What every good rebrand has in common is this: an insight and a commitment to doing it properly.
They happen when the brand you built to get you here is no longer the brand that will get you there.
So how do you know when it’s actually time to rebrand — and I don’t mean to refresh a website or update a colour palette, but to truly rethink the role your brand plays in driving growth?
Smarter business news. Straight to your inbox.
For startup founders, small businesses and leaders. Build sharper instincts and better strategy by learning from Australia’s smartest business minds. Sign up for free.
By continuing, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.
Here are the signals founders and executives should be paying attention to.
1. Your business has evolved, but your brand hasn’t
Most brands outgrow their positioning well before they outgrow their product offerings.
You may have:
Shifted your customer demographic
Moved up (or down) in price
Expanded into new categories or channels
Professionalised the business with new leadership, investors or infrastructure
But your brand still reflects the scrappy, unvalidated version of you from five years ago.
Related Article Block Placeholder
Article ID: 326128
This shows up when the story you’re telling externally no longer matches the reality of the business internally. Your team feels it, and so do your customers. Growth starts to stall because the brand is no longer doing the heavy lifting it should.
2. You’re relying too heavily on discounting to grow
One of the clearest signals it’s time to rebrand is when performance marketing and discounting are doing all of the work.
If growth depends on:
Heavy discounting
Increasing CAC
Short-term bursts of demand rather than sustained momentum
…it’s often a brand problem, rather than a media problem.
Strong brands lower the cost of growth. They improve conversion, drive repeat purchase, increase AOV and create demand that exists before someone sees an ad. If you’re stuck on a hamster wheel of paid acquisition, a rebrand that truly sets you apart and piques interest can be the circuit breaker that allows you to build a more efficient, full-funnel growth engine.
3. You can’t articulate your value in one clear sentence
If you ask five people in your business what the brand stands for and you get five different answers, we have a problem, Houston.
This lack of clarity shows up everywhere:
Inconsistent messaging across channels
Campaigns that look nice but don’t tell a cohesive story
Product launches that don’t quite connect with customers
A rebrand forces alignment. This might not be as drastic as a visual rebrand, but perhaps it’s a strategic rebrand to refine your positioning, values and key messages. It creates a clear point of view and a framework your team can use to make decisions.
Related Article Block Placeholder
Article ID: 324806
4. You’re attracting the wrong customer (or the wrong talent)
If you’re attracting customers who are overly price-sensitive or churn quickly, your brand may be attracting the wrong audience.
The same goes for hiring. If you’re struggling to attract senior talent, creative thinkers, or leaders who can take the business to the next phase, your brand story might be underselling the opportunity.
A rebrand — whether it be a nip/tuck or full face lift — helps you choose who you’re for and bring them into your community.
5. Your brand no longer reflects your ambition
This is the one founders don’t talk about enough.
Sometimes the clearest signal is internal: the brand just doesn’t feel like you anymore. It’s more intuitive, often defined by the long-term plans inside a founder’s head that need to be mapped out on paper for the team.
You’ve grown. Your confidence has grown. Your vision is bigger. But your brand still plays small and you’re ready to take a leap.
Related Article Block Placeholder
Article ID: 323137
Rebrands often coincide with inflection points such as new investment, category expansion, international growth, or a shift from founder-led hustle (read: chaos) to scalable systems and a serious business. The brand needs to rise to meet that ambition.
A true brand is a great oxymoron
The most successful rebrands are driven by strategy, not boredom or trend cycles. They’re timeless, yet find a way to be culturally relevant. They are rooted in insight and excel spreadsheets of data, but are often intuitive and fluid. Brand, in its truest form, is a great oxymoron.
A great brand clarifies direction for you, the team and your customers. It tells everyone what it means to be part of the community. When done well, rebrands unlock growth efficiency and allow founders to build businesses that are recognised not just for what they sell, but for what they stand for — all of which are valuable commodities in tough economic times and when it comes time for you to raise capital or exit.
If you’re feeling friction between where your business is headed and how your brand shows up today, that tension is worth listening to and digging into. Because the cost of not rebranding and the weight of dragging an old identity into a new phase of growth, is often far higher than the investment it takes to do it properly.
